Shedeur Sanders Faces Scrutiny After Disappointing Preseason Finale

Shedeur Sanders, the rookie quarterback drafted by the Cleveland Browns in the fifth round of the 2025 NFL Draft, has become a focal point of controversy following a troubling performance during the team’s preseason finale against the Los Angeles Rams. Sanders, the son of Hall of Famer Deion Sanders, completed only three of six passes for a mere 14 yards and was sacked five times, raising questions about his readiness for the NFL and the support he is receiving from the organization.

One of the most talked-about moments of the game was a particularly brutal 24-yard sack, which was described by Yahoo Sports as Sanders’ ‘worst play of the preseason.’ This performance has led to speculation among fans and analysts alike, suggesting that Sanders may have been set up to fail. The narrative gained traction after he showed visible frustration when he was replaced in the fourth quarter by Tyler Huntley, who subsequently led the Browns to a winning drive. Sanders admitted he was unaware that he had been substituted, having expressed a desire to stay on the field.

Concerns Over Team Dynamics and Support

Overall, Sanders finished the preseason with 17 completions on 29 attempts for 152 yards and two touchdowns. However, the five sacks he endured during the final game raised concerns about both the offensive line’s protection and Sanders’ pocket presence. Former NFL star Eric Dickerson added to the controversy by alleging that Sanders’ draft stock was intentionally suppressed by the league to ‘make an example’ of him, as reported by Dawgs By Nature.

Critics argue that the Browns have not provided the necessary foundation for Sanders to succeed, pointing to the high number of sacks he faced as evidence of potential mishandling. Fan opinions are sharply divided; some supporters regard him as a future star, noting his accolade as the 2024 Big 12 Offensive Player of the Year while detractors mock his early struggles with nicknames such as ‘Shedont Sanders.’

The viral clip of his significant sack has intensified discussions on social media, with searches for terms like ‘Shedeur Sanders worst play’ and ‘Browns sabotaging Shedeur Sanders’ surging. While conspiracy theories surrounding his treatment have gained traction, many analysts dismiss these claims as unfounded. Outlets such as Dawgs By Nature have labeled the sabotage theories as ‘daft,’ emphasizing that the NFL benefits from showcasing talented young players rather than undermining them.

Looking Ahead: Sanders’ Future with the Browns

Most experts agree that Sanders’ challenges are linked to the need for improvement in his pocket presence, timing, and adaptability to professional defenses. Following the preseason, he is expected to start the regular season as the Browns’ fourth-string quarterback, positioned behind veterans Joe Flacco, Jameis Winston, and Tyler Huntley.

Despite limited immediate playing opportunities, the Browns appear committed to Sanders’ development. Executive Vice President Andrew Berry has indicated that the team may carry four quarterbacks this season, allowing Sanders crucial time to adjust to the speed and complexity of the NFL. As the 2025 season unfolds, observers will closely monitor whether Sanders can overcome these initial hurdles and address the surrounding claims of sabotage.