St Peter’s Hill Players Energize Stage with Arsenic and Old Lace

The St Peter’s Hill Players made a notable entrance at the Guildhall Arts Centre on October 10, 2023, debuting their latest production, Arsenic and Old Lace. This screwball comedy marks a shift from their previous hard-edged play, The Thrill of Love, showcasing the group’s versatility. The performance captivated audiences with its high-energy antics surrounding a darkly comedic theme of murder.

This classic play, made famous by the Cary Grant film in the 1940s, revolves around the character of Mortimer Brewster, played by Daniel Ferguson. Ferguson delivered a compelling performance, expertly navigating the range of emotions required for a character who discovers the unsettling reality of his aunts’ actions. Mortimer’s journey includes proposing to his girlfriend Elaine, portrayed by Rachel Armitage, as they navigate the ups and downs of their relationship amid the chaos of the Brewster household.

The story unfolds in the Brooklyn home of Mortimer’s aunts, Abby and Martha, played by Lis Connor and Sharon Antony. These two seemingly innocent, religious women harbor a dark secret: they administer poison to their male lodgers as an act of misguided mercy. Connor and Antony brought depth to their roles, skillfully balancing the comedy and horror inherent in their characters.

As the plot thickens, two additional characters enter the scene: Mortimer’s long-lost brother Jonathan and his ominous companion, Dr. Einstein, played by Paul Keenan and Andy Antony. Keenan’s portrayal of Jonathan is striking, resembling a Frankenstein-like figure complete with facial scars from a surgery performed by Dr. Einstein. Antony’s performance echoes the quiet menace of Peter Lorre, who played the doctor in the original film. Together, these characters enhance the play’s tension and humor.

With its mix of dark comedy and energetic performances, Arsenic and Old Lace continues to entertain audiences at the Guildhall Arts Centre. The play runs tonight, October 10, at 19:30 and again on October 11 at 14:30. Tickets are available for purchase at the Guildhall box office or online at www.guildhallartscentre.com. This production promises to engage viewers with its thrilling combination of laughter and suspense.